Amnesty’s wild claim that Gitmo is a regular ole Gulag prompted a nice response from the ultra-conservative New Republic: Gulag: For the most part, Gulag prisoners provided labor for the Soviet system. Treatment varied widely, but most prisoners lived in overcrowded barracks, and prisoners occasionally killed one another in an effort to find space to … Continue reading “Amnesia International”
Amnesty’s wild claim that Gitmo is a regular ole Gulag prompted a nice response from the ultra-conservative New Republic:
Gulag: For the most part, Gulag prisoners provided labor for the Soviet system. Treatment varied widely, but most prisoners lived in overcrowded barracks, and prisoners occasionally killed one another in an effort to find space to sleep. Deadly dysentery and typhus outbreaks were common. Prisoners often had inadequate clothing to protect themselves from the elements, and most camps lacked running water and heat.
Guantánamo: A recent Time magazine report found that “the best-behaved detainees are held in Camp 4, a medium-security, communal-living environment with as many as 10 beds in a room; prisoners can play soccer or volleyball outside up to nine hours a day, eat meals together and read Agatha Christie mysteries in Arabic. Less cooperative detainees typically live and eat in small, individual cells and get to exercise and shower only twice a week.” Human Rights Watch and other watchdog groups have collected firsthand testimony from prisoners alleging abuses, including the use of dogs, extended solitary confinement, sexual humiliation, and “stress positions.” An official investigation uncovered only minor abuses, and most detainee accusations have not been verified.
Amnesty – which we’re calling Amnesia on account of their sense of history – has some other interesting claims on their web site. Did you know that violence against women is the “greatest human rights scandal of our time?” Amnesia does. Never mind that 60% of violent crime victims in the US are male::
During 1994 men experienced almost 6.6 million violent victimizations; women experienced 5 million. For every 3 violent victimizations of males, there were 2 of females.
…or that 77% of murder victims, or 99% of military deaths, or that women resort to violence in relationships as often as men – when momma ain’t happy, Amnesia ain’t happy and that’s just the way it is.
The current leader of Amnesia, Irene Zubaida Khan, has clearly run it off the rails.
H/T John Cole.
Here’s a good linkie-winkie: Shamnesty International via Protein:
Al Qaeda knows better than any organization that its success depends on peeling both Muslim-world support and U.S. public support away from the Bush administration’s war on terrorism. Consider the quasi-reasoned tone Osama bin Laden adopted in a recording he allegedly made last November, calling on the “people of America” to drop their support for the president. The recording was full of contemporary and historical allusions, as is the training manual. If Al Qaeda’s savvy enough for that, it’s savvy enough to know that civil liberties – even the civil liberties of accused bad guys – are a hot-button issue in the U.S.
In the U.S. alone, there are 65-plus lawsuits claiming abuse of detainees at American hands. There are still more legal demarches overseas. We’ve seen inaccurate Koran-desecration stories send Muslim crowds raging in protest. We have regular accounts of arrested terrorism suspects being sent to third countries where they face torture-driven interrogation. And, as if on cue, we have Amnesty International calling the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, “the gulag of our time.”
Naturally, the Bush administration is berating the organization for such a ridiculous comparison. After all, Guantanamo Bay’s guards are under the microscope of human-rights lawyers all the time. The inmates are fairly treated. The guard-throws-Koran-in-toilet story was false. And claims that the inmates’ detention oversteps the boundaries of international law have been responded to at the highest levels. Besides, the 500-600 Guantanamo detainees wouldn’t be there if Al Qaeda hadn’t killed 2,948 Americans and others on Sept 11, 2001.
The cottage industry stuff is spot on. Read it and see.